5427 Old Lake Shore

A rare opportunity to own a private slice of Lake Erie living, without the waterfront price tag. Set on over an acre along one of the most scenic stretches of Old Lake Shore Road, this beautifully positioned ranch delivers sweeping lake views, deeded beach access, and the kind of peaceful, spacious lifestyle that's nearly impossible to find this close to Buffalo.

Views That Stop You in Your Tracks

The elevated front patio, added in 2023, was designed with one purpose: to frame the lake. Whether it's morning coffee with the sun climbing over Erie, or an evening glass of wine as the sky turns gold, this is where you'll want to be. Panoramic water views greet you the moment you arrive, and they never get old.

Deeded Beach & Water Access

Step off the property and directly onto Lake Erie. Swimming, kayaking, paddleboarding, sunrise walks along the shore, it's all here, secured by deeded access that's yours alone. This is the Lake Erie lifestyle, without compromise.

A Ranch That Lives Large

At 1,671 square feet of single-level living, this home is bigger than it sounds. Two generously sized bedrooms, 1.5 baths, and a layout that flexes with your needs. The expansive main living area works beautifully as a combined living and dining room, while the oversized second living space could just as easily serve as a family room, game room, or entertainer's lounge. Large windows throughout pull the scenery inside and keep every room bright.

The eat-in kitchen features solid surface countertops, a full appliance package (including washer and dryer), and pantry storage. Hardwood, tile, and carpet flooring throughout. Solid surface finishes. Pull-down attic stairs for added storage.

Outdoor Living, Done Right

Out back, a Trex deck overlooks a beautifully treed, fully fenced yard, 1.04 acres of genuine privacy. Whether you're hosting a summer cookout, letting the dog run, or simply disappearing for an afternoon, this backyard delivers. A 1.5-car attached garage rounds out the picture with practical, year-round convenience.

Mechanicals & Efficiency

Thermal insulated windows. Central air. Gas forced-air furnace. Gas hot water tank replaced in 2023. The home sits on a full basement/crawlspace with all mechanicals neatly accessible. Circuit breaker electric. Connected to public water and sewer.

The Bottom Line

Year-round home, weekend retreat, or investment property, 5427 Old Lake Shore Road works for all of it. One acre. Lake views. Beach access. Single-level living. Easy access to Route 5 and everything Buffalo has to offer.

Open House: Sunday, May 31 | 11:00 AM – 1:00 PM